Book Review: The 9/11 Wars

News

burke

It is ten years since the fateful 9/11 attacks, a day that for many serves as a dissecting line in history between “before” and “after”, between a world before that tragic attack which claimed the lives of almost 3,000 people, and after its even more tragic repercussions that resulted in a death toll many times greater. Jason Burke defines the fatal chain of events sparked by the 9/11 attacks – which itself was an effect as much as a cause – as the “9/11 Wars”, and in his book of the same name takes us on a journey beginning with the Al Qaeda attacks on the World Trade Centre and Pentagon, through the Afghan and Iraq wars, and ending with the “Arab Spring” currently blooming in the Middle East. Jason Burke is the perfect man for the job, as one of the longest serving British foreign correspondents, he has a rich experience of all the places he describes and talks about in his book, whether this is Waziristan, Kandahar, or Fallujah. Burke also has a strong background in this subject, and his previous critically acclaimed book “Al Qaeda: The true story of radical Islam” remains vital reading for anyone wanting to know more about Al Qaeda in particular or Islamic radicalism in general.

“The 9/11 Wars” focuses on the ordinary people affected by this war. Burke makes sure to talk to everybody involved in this sprawling conflict, from academics to spies, mullahs to market traders. He talks to rank-and-file soldiers as well as generals, and even suicide bombers who changed their mind at the last minute. Burke says his aim is to provide “a grubby view from below” of this conflict, however he does much more than this, providing us with a coherent vision of the vast sprawling fabric of the global ‘war on terror.”

Burke avoids generalizations about the causes of the 9/11 attacks, and indeed their repercussions, concentrating instead on local characterizations. He argues that the series of struggles we have seen over the past decade are not a result of clash of civilization, or confrontation between different religions, or between the secular and the faithful, the East verses West, nor even between the “global haves” and the “global have-nots.” Rather, he views the 9/11 wars as being a “chaotic matrix of multivalent, confused but also lethal wars” where each country or community has adapted the struggle the conflict to its own unique situation. Russian President Vladimir Putin, for example, attempted to use the 9/11 attacks to “cast the brutal war in the southern breakaway republic of Chechnya as a battle against Islamic radicalism.”

He is extremely clear on the extremely complex and multifaceted nature of this conflict, and avoids ideological narratives that attempt to neatly summarize this chaotic conflict, whether this is from Al Qaeda or George W. Bush. He does not view Al Qaeda as a unified “axis of evil” but rather as an “amorphous, dynamic and fragmented movement based more on personal relations and a shared world view than on formal membership of an organization.”

“The 9/11 Wars” covers all the major struggles that have occurred since, and indeed because of, the 9/11 attacks: the toppling of the Taliban and Saddam Hussein regimes, the bloody insurgency and civil war in Iraq, the Al Qaeda bombings in London and Madrid, and returning to the resurgent Taliban in Afghanistan five years later.

He describes the Iraq war as a “grotesque strategic error”, and captures both the US and Al Qaeda’s failures in this conflict. Both viewed this as being part of a global war, and failed to pay attention to Iraq’s particular context, local identity, and dynamics. Burke also writes strongly about the ineptitude of the western policies on the ground in Iraq.

A long-term resident of New Delhi with an intimate knowledge of south Asia, Burke writes extremely well on the social and political fabric of the conflict in Afghanistan and Pakistan, and the tribal areas between them. His chapter on this lawless region and the radical groups that have made it their home is perhaps the best in the book and he writes that the Lashkar-e-Taiba is “arguably the biggest violent Islamic extremist organization in the world.” Burke writes authoritatively of the relationship between Pakistan’s military intelligence service and the jihadists they hope to use in their regional contest with India, stressing that this is today as great a threat to international stability as Al Qaeda.

Indeed Burke agrees that Al Qaeda is significantly weaker today than it was a decade ago, and that its ideology has lost much of its appeal in the Middle East, particularly in light of the “Arab Spring.” However he is not yet ready to completely write off Al Qaeda, stressing that it still poses a significant threat in both Pakistan and Afghanistan.

Burke’s account of the past decade stands out from other such accounts written by academics and diplomats, thanks, in part, to his first hand regional experience and expertise, and he is able to draw the reader in and describe events in a convincing and attention-grabbing manner. However, for all the interesting anecdotes and personal observations that pepper this book, it is as much an academic or scholarly work as it is an example of first-rate reportage.

The book’s greatest strength lies in its detailed, balanced overview of the past decade, rather than it advancing any grand new theory about what remains a complex and ever-changing situation. However at a time when more books than ever have been published about terrorism – 11,000 according to Burke in comparison to less than 1,000 prior to 9/11 –the “9/11 Wars” must certainly be considered one of the best.

This article was originally published here.